5 May 2025 2 min read

Big Consulting's High-Stakes Game of Chicken

AI is reshaping the industry, but no leader wants to move first

U
Usman SheikhPublished on LinkedIn
Big Consulting's High-Stakes Game of Chicken

The Collective Paralysis

Everyone in big consulting knows what's coming.

No one wants to move first.

The consulting business thrived on a simple formula:

→ Hire junior analysts cheaply

→ Bill clients at premium rates

→ Target 75%+ utilization

→ Expand headcount to fuel growth

→ Leverage brand prestige for margins

→ Justify fees through complexity

The Breaking Business Model

Today, that formula is breaking down:

→ AI matches junior output at a fraction of the cost

→ Top talent achieves more with smaller teams

→ Utilization targets lose relevance

→ Clients challenge the premium on human leverage

→ Margins driven by headcount expansion quickly erode

Privately, leaders across the Big 4 and global SIs admit:

Significant layoffs and deep restructuring are inevitable.

The Strategic Hesitation

Yet, they pause, trapped by uncertainty:

→ Deep cuts risk immediate reputational harm

→ Governance structures prevent decisive action

→ Thousands of careers and families hang in the balance

This hesitation feels safe but quietly builds strategic debt.

Salary freezes, stealth layoffs, and hiring slowdowns treat symptoms, not causes.

Each day without decisive action:

→ Competitors steadily capture market share

→ Restructuring becomes more costly and complex

→ Clients quietly shift to innovative challengers

The Leadership Inflection Point

This isn't about timing. It's about courage.

Weak leaders wait for clarity. Strong leaders act through uncertainty.

Great leaders disrupt themselves while winning.

Question for the audience, if you were in charge of one of the Big 4 or global SIs today, what would your plan be to navigate this inflection point?

Summary

Big consulting faces inevitable disruption. No one dares move first.

Traditional model crumbling as AI matches junior output
Premium fees and utilization targets losing relevance
Leaders acknowledge need for deep restructuring
Fear of reputation damage causes paralysis
Delay builds strategic debt while competitors advance
Strong leaders act through uncertainty
Great ones disrupt themselves while winning

How would you navigate this inflection point as a Big 4 leader?

U
Usman SheikhPublished on LinkedIn
615 reactions
225 comments
59 reposts

Interested? Join the discussion in Linkedin


Why do readers subscribe to my Daily Update?

Stay ahead of the curve

The world of knowledge work is rapidly changing. Every day you get one tip to stay ahead.

Under 400 words

Updates you can quickly skim through and apply straight away at work.

Delivered consistently

I have been writing daily for over 2 years, sending one insightful note everyday to your inbox.

Phone showing newsletter preview